Remember, the reading notes for Frankenstein will be turned in March 12th, not March 10th.
Here is a map that shows Walton's and Victor's locations in the beginning of the book. Click to embiggen.
Thursday, March 5, 2015
Tuesday, March 3, 2015
Reading Response 6
Reading Response 6 - Frankenstein, letter 1 - chapter 4
Due: Thursday, March 5
Choose one. Provide specific evidence from the novel to support your argument.
1. Walton’s desire is to discover the North Pole and the external conflicts he faces stem from that. But what drives him to do it? In other words, describe Walton’s inner conflict. Look at what we know of his past and consider comparing Walton with what we know of his sister, Mrs. Margaret Saville.
2. Compare and contrast the ambitions of Victor and Walton. How do the two men see their responsibilities to themselves and others? What kinds of values and motivations may be operating for each person?
3. What do you think of Victor at this point? What kind of character is he? Consider looking at his relationship with his family, with Elizabeth, and/or to his education.
4. Choose your own focus for analysis.
Frankenstein reading questions
Use these questions to help focus your reading. If you want to print this out, a pdf of this is on the class site through MyPortal.
1. Is Victor Frankenstein a dynamic character? In other words, does he change throughout the novel? Does he learn anything?
2. Is the novel saying that too much knowledge is a bad thing? Are exploration and discovery portrayed as misguided or noble?
3. What does the novel tell us about education? Look at both Victor and the Creature, but don’t forget Clerval and Safie. Does education help characters to overcome barriers or does it create more problems?
4. What is the cause of Victor’s guilt, according to him? According to the Creature? According to you?
5. Which characters have a voice in society and which do not? Why are certain characters denied voice? Is there a pattern?
6. Is the Creature good or evil? Is he innately so or is he made that way? Is there a villain in this novel?
7. Why does Victor remain silent about the Creature until the end? Is his silence justified?
8. Why doesn’t the Creature simply kill Victor early on? Look at how the Creature behaves over Victor’s coffin. Does this scene give you any other insights as to why the Creature didn’t kill Victor?
9. Look at how women are treated in this novel. Is there some kind of pattern? Do the women inhabit similar worlds? Contrast that with the worlds inhabited by the men.
10. Is Victor a reliable narrator? Is Walton? Is the Creature? Who do you trust the most? Why?
Frankenstein reading notes
Take reading notes for every group of chapters assigned from Frankenstein. For instance, for Thursday take notes for "Letter 1" through "Chapter 4." We will be turning in the notes twice: Thursday, March 12 and Thursday, March 19. A template is below. Either download it and print it out or follow the format on your own piece of paper.
Friday, February 27, 2015
Research paper outline due Tuesday, March 3rd
In many ways, you are at the most difficult stage of a research paper. You need to sort through your secondary sources and figure out what they are saying. Then you need to consider how they relate to your primary text and how they may answer your research question. Some of you have found that the sources you have looked at don't answer your question at all. In this situation, there are two ways to proceed. One is to get help from a research librarian and find new sources. The other is to change your focus based on the information you have gotten so far.
Again, this is often the hardest part. It is common to feel frustrated, confused, defeated, to fall into the "dark night of the soul." This, too, is part of the process. Take breaks to clear your head. But also don't neglect to put the necessary time into reading and thinking.
The outline due Tuesday is just an initial sketch. It's your best idea of what the paper will look like based on the evidence and ideas you have now. As I said in class, the format is up to you. I definitely want to see a tentative thesis statement and a basic flow of the argument in the form of the points of the body paragraphs. Literature and Its Writers has some good advice for forming a thesis out of research notes on pages 1629-1631. If you want more examples of outlines, the Owl has some good pages here and here. And the slideshow I presented in class Thursday can be found as a pdf on the class site through MyPortal (look under "files," the name is "MLA-1B-researchpaper2.pdf").
(the image at the top is from Steal Like an Artist by Austin Kleon)
Thursday, February 26, 2015
Reading Response 5
When I wrote the syllabus, I didn't take into account that some people were going to rewrite Essay 2. Because of that, I've decided that we are going to do Reading Response 5 as an in-class exercise. So it is not due for homework Tuesday. Still, look through the poems and annotate them as you read them. Be ready to write on one in class Tuesday.
Tuesday, February 24, 2015
Essay 2 rewrite
If you plan to rewrite Essay 2, it is due in one week. In other words, hand it in on or before Tuesday, March 3rd. Hand in the rewrite with the original draft and also submit an electronic copy to Turnitin.
Here are some general comments on Essay 2:
Here are some general comments on Essay 2:
- Weak thesis statements. Some of the papers had thesis statements that were more factual than analytical. For instance, many papers were about how characters in the two stories being written about change themselves by the ends of the stories. This is more of a plot point than an analysis. If you look at the actual prompt, it asks you to look at why this happens. How or why questions tend to create deeper thesis statements. If your thesis merely states what happened, it's probably not very analytical. Having a weak thesis tends to lead to many other problems.
- Plot summary. Some papers lost sight of their own thesis statements and devolved into plot summary. This may be due to the point above, not having a very strong thesis. Keep in mind that the goal is not to describe both stories, but to explore a pattern in both stories.
- Organize around your points. Again, I think this problem is due to not having a strong thesis. Anyway, you should organize your paper around the points you wish to make. Don't simply organize your paper around the texts. As a teacher, I can tell that students aren't really analyzing if they can only talk about a story in the order the plot is presented. Analysis requires the breaking apart of the original structure.
- Incorrect MLA. Proper MLA is one of the requirements of this class. There are many resources that can help you, such as our book and the Owl.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
